Norbit did not kill Eddie Murphy’s career, but it mortally wounded his reputation as a leading man. For years, the film was cited as the reason Murphy lost the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor for Dreamgirls (2006). The narrative went: Oscar voters saw Norbit —which opened just weeks before the Academy Awards—and recoiled. Whether true or urban legend, it crystallized the film’s legacy as a “vote repeller.”
Flash forward to adulthood. Norbit (Murphy, in a subdued, soft-spoken performance) is a meek, downtrodden accountant trapped in a loveless, terrifying marriage to Rasputia (Murphy in a fat suit and heavy prosthetics). Rasputia is a monstrous force of nature: loud, sexually aggressive, physically abusive, and profoundly entitled. She and her three hulking, dim-witted brothers (also played by Murphy, in an astonishing feat of multi-role chutzpah) run the town of Boiling Springs, Tennessee, with an iron, spandex-clad fist. Norbit -2007-
In 2007, audiences laughed. In retrospect, the laughter curdles. Rasputia is not a character; she is a caricature weaponized for easy jokes. The film’s humor relies on the shock of seeing a slim, handsome Eddie Murphy “trapped” in this body, performing a minstrel show of femininity and size. The infamous bathtub scene, where a naked Rasputia crushes a flotation device and sends a tidal wave of water through the house, is technically impressive physical comedy. But it’s impossible to separate the craft from the cruelty. The film takes a vulnerable demographic—plus-size Black women—and turns them into a punchline for 100 minutes. Norbit did not kill Eddie Murphy’s career, but
No discussion of Norbit can bypass the towering, controversial figure of Rasputia. Murphy’s performance is a grotesque carnival act: he wears a 70-pound silicone fat suit, his face stretched into a permanent scowl with a tiny, pursed mouth and fierce eyes. Rasputia is written as a litany of the worst possible stereotypes about large Black women—she is loud, domineering, hypersexual, gluttonous, and physically violent. Whether true or urban legend, it crystallized the
Ultimately, Norbit is not a good movie. It is not a so-bad-it’s-good movie. It is a so-wrong-it’s-fascinating movie. It stands as a testament to a particular moment in American comedy when the only rule was “make them laugh, no matter the collateral damage.” For some, it is an guilty pleasure; for others, an unwatchable relic. But for anyone interested in the limits of comedy, the weight of representation, and the spectacular, sweaty, latex-bound ambition of Eddie Murphy, Norbit is essential, uncomfortable viewing. It is a film you can’t defend, but you also can’t look away from.