Prosecutor Dana Whitford laid out a devastating timeline. Simon, a former wealth manager and court-appointed guardian, was entrusted with the estate of 87-year-old retired neurologist Dr. Helena Voss. Dr. Voss had no living relatives and named Simon as both her power of attorney and primary beneficiary in a 2021 will.
But it was the emotional testimony from a neighbor, retired nurse , that sealed the emotional weight of the case. Stiles testified that she found Dr. Voss wandering the garden at 2 a.m. in a nightgown, disoriented and crying, repeating, "Olivia took my keys. She says I can't leave." Olivia Simon Guilty Ewp.57
The evidence was largely paper-based: $340,000 in "consulting fees" to a shell company Simon owned, the sale of Dr. Voss’s heirloom piano for $80 (later traced to Simon’s personal storage unit), and 147 forged signatures on checks made out to "cash." Prosecutor Dana Whitford laid out a devastating timeline
"Olivia Simon did not care for Dr. Voss," Whitford said in her closing statement. "She collected her. She isolated a brilliant woman with the beginnings of mild cognitive impairment, manipulated her medications, and systematically drained a lifetime of savings under the legal cover of 'care expenses.' Ewp.57 exists precisely for predators in cardigans." Stiles testified that she found Dr
The courtroom, packed to capacity for the final day of the three-week trial, fell into a heavy silence as the foreperson read the decision. Simon, 34, stood motionless, her hands clasped in front of her. Unlike the composed, polished figure who first entered the plea of "not guilty" six months ago, she appeared hollowed out—a stark contrast to the poised strategist the prosecution painted throughout the trial.
CENTRAL DISTRICT COURTHOUSE – After seven hours of deliberation, a jury of eight women and four men returned a unanimous verdict: Olivia Simon is guilty on all counts pertaining to code Ewp.57.